Issue 1: Does a “Boy Crisis” or a “Boy Problem” exist and require policy attention?
A movement to deal with the problems of boys is still in its infancy in the United States. The issue is controversial. Does a “boy problem” or a “boy crisis” actually exist which needs policy attention? According to some analysts, girls are outstripping boys in many important areas, such as reading and writing skills and college attendance and graduation. With the decline of high-paying work in traditional male occupations such as manufacturing and the increase of high-paying work in occupations requiring professional and information processing skills, men without a college education have been left behind. Others argue that the “boy crisis” represents a backlash against the success of women, who still earn less and occupy fewer high-prestige positions in American society.
Research and Policy Questions: Are boys actually in trouble, and what is the evidence? Consider mental health, such as suicide rates, as well as school achievement and college attendance and completion. What are the reasons for the change in attention to boys? What is the likelihood that the “boy problem” will receive local, state, or national attention as did the “girl problem”? What cultural, economic, and ideological changes and commitments are driving this issue?Key Sources:
1. American Association for University Women. (1992). How schools shortchange girls. Washington, DC: American Association of University Women.
The American Association of University Women focused national attention on the educational problems of girls, arguing that the schools were shortchanging girls, that girls were behind in mathematics and science, that girls suffered from low self-esteem and received less attention from teachers. This report supported and spurred a myriad of educational efforts, such as mathematics and science summer programs for girls and conferences and institutes for teachers on the needs of girls. While dated, this report is still an excellent summary of the issues and data sources. Similar programs may help boys. For more recent information from a girls’ advocacy perspective, see the AAUW web page: www.aauw.org
2. Kleinfeld, Judith. (1998). The myth that schools shortchange girls. Washington, DC: Women’s Freedom Network, 1998. www.uaf.edu/northern/schools/myth.html
See also Kleinfeld, J. (1999). Student performance: Males versus females. The Public Interest, 3-20.
This report and article critique the research report issued by the AAUW and provide evidence for the position that boys and girls have different types of educational problems and needs, as opposed to the position that only girls are shortchanged in schools. While girls need more attention in such subjects as the physical sciences and advanced mathematics, boys need more attention in the development of literacy. This report also points out the disproportionate number of boys diagnosed with autism, attention deficit disorder, and other learning disabilities and the greater variability of boys, which places them both at the top of the heap and the bottom of the barrel.
3. Sommers, Christine Hoff. (2000). The war against boys: How misguided feminism is harming our young men. New York: Touchstone. This is a central source for the position that the behavior of male children has been pathologized in schools. Feminist excesses have created a culture of disapproval of males where boys are perceived as violent, sexual harrassers, and responsible for the sins of the patriarchy. These cultural attitudes amount to an “undeclared war against boys” and an educational movement to “feminize” boys.
4. Mead, S. (2006). The truth about girls and boys. Washington, DC: Education Sector. http://www.girlscoalition.org/uploads/research/ESO_BoysAndGirls.pdf
This research report argues that the “boy crisis” is not grounded in the data, that news stories on the problems of boys reflect the desire for a new “man bites dog” angle, and that boy advocates are advancing political agendas and personal interests. Boys are making progress on the National Assessment of Educational Progress tests and increasing in college attendance, not only girls. Mead argues that class and race are far more important than gender and should be the major focus of policy attention, although she acknowledges that low-income, urban, and minority boys are in trouble.
5. Weaver-Hightower, M. (2003). “The boy turn” in research on gender and education. Review of Educational Research, 73, 471-498.
This article examines the reasons for greater attention to boys and why policy-makers and researchers have become interested in the issue. He identifies eight important influences, including conservative and backlash politics, parental concerns and pressures resulting from the media’s highlighting of the problems of boys, and the “thrill of the new” for researchers and educators. Rooted in a feminist and progressive political perspective, this article argues that attention to the problems of minority boys is well-founded as well as the need for impartial research on best programs and practices that go beyond the claims of those who are involved in them.
-
Recent Posts
Archives
Contents
- about westmichigandad – site overview
- Audio
- Books
- Fathers
- 52 Things Kids Need from a Dad: What Fathers Can Do to Make a Lifelong Difference
- A Family’s Heartbreak: A Parent’s Introduction to Parental Alienation
- A Father’s Love
- Big Russ and Me: Father and Son: Lessons of Life
- Big Shoes: In Celebration Of Dads And Fatherhood
- Blind Baseball A Father’s War
- Boys Adrift: The Five Factors Driving the Growing Epidemic of Unmotivated Boys and Underachieving Young Men
- Championship Fathering: How to Win at Being a Dad
- Divorce poison : how to protect your family from bad-mouthing and brainwashing
- Divorce poison : protecting the parent-child bond from a vindictive ex 1st ed
- Does feminism discriminate against men? : a debate
- Fatherhood
- Fine Young Man: What Parents, Mentors and Educators Can Do to Shape Adolescent Boys into Exceptional Men
- Hear Our Cry: Boys in Crisis
- It’s a Boy!: Understanding Your Son’s Development from Birth to Age 18
- Jak neotrávit děti rozvodem
- Letters to a Young Brother: MANifest Your Destiny
- Nurture the Nature: Understanding and Supporting Your Child’s Unique Core Personality
- Raising Cain: Protecting the Emotional Life of Boys
- Real Boys: Rescuing Our Sons from the Myths of Boyhood
- Revoluce v porozvodové péči o děti
- Revoluce v porozvodové péči o děti : otcovský faktor a mystika mateřství
- Rookie Dad: Thoughts on First-Time Fatherhood
- Rozvodové jedy
- Slyšení nezletilého dítěte před opatrovnickým soudem : (tři studie problému)
- Speaking of Boys: Answers to the Most Asked Questions About Raising Sons
- The 7 secrets of Effective Fathers Becoming the Father your children need.
- The case for Father Custody
- The Good Son: Shaping the Moral Development of Our Boys and Young Men
- for Children
- Men related
- Hoyle’s rules of game 3rd rev. and updated ed
- Life Without Father
- Life without Father: Compelling New Evidence That Fatherhood and Marriage Are Indispensable for the Good of Children and Society
- Life Without the Father – Stewart
- Manhood: The Rise and Fall of the Penis
- Maximized Manhood
- Sperm Wars: Infidelity, Sexual Conflict, and Other Bedroom Battles
- Sperm Wars: The Evolutionary Logic of Love and Lust
- Sperm Wars: The Science of Sex
- The art of war
- The Great Gatsby
- The myth of male power : why men are the disposable sex
- The myth of male power : why men are the disposable sex
- The Naked Man: A Study of the Male Body
- The Prince
- The Republic
- PDF’s located here
- relevant to everyone
- 1-2-3 Magic Effective discipline for children 2-12 3rd Edition
- Boys and Girls Learn Differently! A Guide for Teachers and Parents: Revised 10th Anniversary Edition
- Boys Should Be Boys: 7 Secrets to Raising Healthy Sons
- Castaway Kid: One Man’s Search for Hope and Home
- Come On People: On the Path from Victims to Victors
- Conflict behavior & linkage politics.
- Divorce Busting
- Domestic Violence: The 12 Things You Aren’t Supposed to Know
- False Accusations: Guilty Until Proven Innocent
- Friend of the Court ENEMY of the Family
- Helping Boys Succeed in School
- In Their Own Words: The Wisdom and Passion of Our Founding Fathers
- The custody revolution : the father factor and the motherhood mystique
- The Federalist Papers
- The Garbage Generation
- The Men They Will Become: The Nature and Nurture of Male Character
- The Minds of Boys: Saving Our Sons From Falling Behind in School and Life
- The Miracle of Sons: Celebrating the Boys in Our Lives
- The Miracle of Sons: Celebrating the Boys in Our Lives
- The Purpose of Boys: Helping Our Sons Find Meaning, Significance, and Direction in Their Lives
- The Trouble with Boys: A Surprising Report Card on Our Sons, Their Problems at School, and What Parents and Educators Must Do
- The War Against Boys: How Misguided Feminism Is Harming Our Young Men
- The Wonder of Boys: What Parents, Mentors and Educators Can Do to Shape Boys into Exceptional Men
- The Wonder of Girls: Understanding the Hidden Nature of Our Daughters
- Sam Fryman: the complete works
- 01 – A Mens Liberation Guide to Women
- 02 – A Womens Liberation Guide to Men
- 03 – Kundalini :Preventing the Apocalypse
- 04 – How to Meditate
- 05 – A Men’s and Women’s Liberation Update
- 06 – The Myth of the Teenage Rebellion
- 07 – What is Intelligence
- 08 – Kundalini : A Personal Experience
- 09 – Feminal Farm
- 10 – The Innocent Persons’ Guide to Law
- 11 – Understanding Female Sexuality and Porn
- 12 – Freedom of Speech and the Maitreya
- 13 – A Farewell Message from Sam Fryman
- 14 – An Innocent Persons Guide to the Da Vinci Code
- 15 – The Psychology of Prejudice
- 16 – Afraid of Women
- Value Deal
- written by or about Feminists
- #515 (no title)
- A dangerous liaison : a revelatory new biography of Simone de Beauvoir and Jean-Paul Sartre
- Andrea Dworkin 2nd Ed.
- Debating sexual correctness : pornography, sexual harassment, date rape and the politics of sexual equality
- Deuxième sexe. English The second sex
- Feminism and Marxism : a place to begin, a way to go
- Feminism and methodology : social science issues
- Feminism, marxism, method and the state: an Agenda for Theory
- Feminist interpretations of Simone de Beauvoir
- Feminist jurisprudence
- Going too far : the personal chronicle of a feminist
- Heartbreak : the political memoir of a feminist militant
- Love, power, and knowledge : towards a feminist transformation of the sciences
- Marxism and the interpretation of culture
- Radically speaking : feminism reclaimed
- Sex Equality: Family Law
- Simone de Beauvoir, philosophy & and feminism
- Sisterhood is forever : the women’s anthology for a new millennium
- Sisterhood is global : the international women’s movement anthology
- The conceptual practices of power : a feminist sociology of knowledge
- The Webbs, Fabianism and Feminism: Fabianism and the Political Economy of Everyday Life
- Why the Gender Gap Won’t Go Away. Ever.
- Fathers
- Essays and Monographs
- Links
- Men who made the world a better place
- Research
- about Fathers and children
- A Family Resource Guide on International Parental Kidnapping
- Black Single Custodial Fathers: Factors Influencing the Decision to Parent – Roberta L. Coles
- Child Cost Economics and Litigation Issues – Rogers & Bieniewicz
- COSTSHARE Model.CRC20010505.Rogers
- Fathers are critical to their children’s development…
- Fink’s rebuttal of Wallerstein
- GEORGIA’S CHILD SUPPORT GUIDELINES—NO ECONOMIC BASIS:
- Hyde-Woolsey Child Support Bill – Oral Testimony
- Hyde-Woolsey Child Support Bill—HR 1488 – written testimony – R. Mark Rogers
- Issue 1: Does a “Boy Crisis” or a “Boy Problem” exist and require policy attention?
- Issue 4: The Gender Gap in College Enrollment and Success
- Issue 5: Creating “boy-friendly” classrooms
- Issue 6: What economic and cultural changes create males who flounder in young adulthood?
- Mama Says…
- Matrilineal Ascent/Patrilineal Descent: The Gender Imbalance in American Jewish Life
- Minority Report of the Georgia Commission on Child Support
- No Map to Manhood
- PARENTAL RIGHTS AND DUE PROCESS
- POP’S CULTURE:
- Promoting Better Fathering Among Divorced NonResident Fathers
- R. Mark Rogers, The “Cost Shares” Child Support Guideline, June 1, 2001 – GA (State of Georgia, USA)
- Relocation of children after divorce and Children’s best interest
- The consequences of divorce for financial living standards in later life
- The Consequences of Divorce for Parents
- The Effects of Partnership Instability on Parenting…
- THE STATE OF AMERICAN BOYHOOD
- The State of American Manhood
- The surprising truth about Fathers, children and divorce – Braver with O’Connell and Tarcher
- The Surprising truth about Fathers, Children, and Divorce
- To stabilize and preserve the Family
- Why Georgia’s Child Support Guidelines Are Unconstitutional: Economic Exhibits
- With this ring…
- [Economic Consequence One] Why Minnesota’s Child Support Guidelines Are Unconstitutional” -Rogers
- Definitions
- Kinsey Institute study finds women want sex more than men, men want to cuddle
- The Cost Shares Child Support Guideline—A Common
- about Fathers and children
- The Billion Dollar Man
- THE FATHER OF TODAY’S CHILD SUPPORT PUBLIC POLICY, HIS PERSONAL EXPLOITATION OF THE SYSTEM, AND THE FALLACY OF HIS “INCOME SHARES” MODEL
- Visual
- Why Georgia’s Child Support – Economic Exhibits
Categories